Help us raise $300,000 for NCR!

We have raised $158,746 from 784 supporters. We are 53% of the way to our goal!

Benedict and the Jews

by Dennis Coday

View Author Profile

dcoday@ncronline.org

Join the Conversation

January 26, 2010

Pope Benedict's visit Jan. 17 to the Great Synagogue of Rome caused quite a stir in some quarters. NCR senior correspondent John L Allen Jr. wrote about visit, , and later tried to eplain it, Making Sense of Benedict’s Jewish Policy, and later to put it into context, A theologian-pope sidelines theology.

Over on Belief.net, Rabbi Brad Hirschfield, comments on Allen's analysis, Making Sense of Benedict XVI. Read the full column, but here's the money quote:

... it's remarkable hubris on our part to assume that the leader of more than 1 billion Catholics is primarily concerned with us! We need to get over ourselves, don't you think? I will say this though about Allen's analysis of the Pope's thinking: anyone who thinks that they can be whoever they want to be internally, without that effecting who they are in the "outside world", is seriously kidding themselves. So while I have no concerns for example, about Catholics returning to a mass which occasionally includes a prayer for the conversion of the Jews, perhaps they should - not for our sake, but for their own.

Latest News

Pope Francis delivers his homily during the closing Mass of the synod on synodality in St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican Oct. 27, 2024. (CNS/Lola Gomez)
Vatican

Cardinals poised to pursue the more inclusive, open church championed by Pope Francis

James V. GrimaldiSoli Salgado

Francis dreamed of a house always open to all

Opinion

Outside agendas will not dictate this conclave

Michael Sean Winters
A prelate takes an oath of secrecy May 5, 2025, in preparation for the conclave at the Vatican to elect a new pope. The staff of the cardinals' residence hall, medical assistants and even the cardinals' bus driver took an oath swearing to protect the cardinals' privacy and the conclave's secrecy. (CNS/Vatican Media)
Vatican

The conclave: A detailed explainer of the secret ritual that elects the pope

Camillo Barone

Advertisement